For Valentine's Day I think that typical choices would be red and pink. I am currently trying to use up my bottle of Champneys Pink so have been reaching for that a lot this year for Valentine's. A good red would be Barry M Blood Orange.
Blood Orange is more of a red based polish than a orange as the name suggests. Vibrant and bright red cream polish.
Gloriana is a shimmer burnt orange type of shade which I really liked for autumn, and is very unique in my collection.
However out of the three I particularly liked Rose Bower, a rich berry holographic shade. Which is why Rose Bower ended up being the winner of this round.